BK, I am well aware of the (few) positive things you had to say about BROADWAY: THE AMERICAN MUSICAL, but your discussions about it have been predominantly negative, and all I was/am trying to do is reiterate that as a documentary, it had a little something to offer most anyone interested in the field and for a novice to the subject but someone who cared about musical theater, is would have been an entertaining way to spend a few hours. No, no great revelations for we old school veterans of the Broadway wars, but certainly a documentary of some merit.
Today, I got BROADWAY: THE GOLDEN AGE, and watched it from first to last including the special features (which explains why I'm hours late logging onto this site today). Yes, it's wonderful, moving, VALUABLE as a source of opinion and fact about the theater. And the fact that it covers plays as well as musicals makes it quite different from the other documentary. I really liked it a lot.
But it did contain at least one error that I noticed - a subtitle on some street footage that read New York-1955 with THE MIRACLE WORKER marquee clearly in the shot. It wasn't on Broadway in 1955. And didn't you, bk, have trouble with the movie footage (STREETCAR, MEMBER OF THE WEDDING)contained in this documentary (I remember you loathed the movie footage in the other documentary)? And this even used a DAMN YANKEES trailer with VERY distracting sell blurbs along with the visuals.
So, it was a great documentary, but it wasn't perfect either. And I certainly agree that the upcoming documentary footage doesn't resonate like the footage in the other documentary.