AMERICAN IDOL had pretty much a dud show tonight. I didn't think the BeeGees/Gibb music would be especially suitable for solo singers, and I was right.
Melinda was solidly professional on both her songs. I thought Blake did much better than the judges gave him credit for doing. I wasn't nearly as impressed with Jordin's first song as they were and felt both of her songs pointed up her basic weaknesses: a weak low end, a shaky head voice, and pitch problems in her upper belt range.
As for LaKisha, she was my least favorite tonight. As she has done with almost every single mentor the show has had, she totally ignored the advice on both of her songs, and they were the poorer for her choices.
My order:
Melinda, Blake, Jordin, and LaKisha. I think LaKisha should go home.