I liked IDOL tonight. I think this is the first time we have heard every semifinalist sing a bit during this last episode. True, I would have liked lots more, but we still got to hear something from everyone.
I was puzzled by a couple of choices. My favorites among the women were Melinda, the background singer, and the single mother (don't remember her name).
Of the men, I think the witty, curly-haired bigger guy has an amazing voice, my favorite of the excerpts we heard. (And Simon had the nerve to tell him he didn't think he had one of the better voices but had an excellent personality. I felt he had an outstanding voice. Of course, Simon got to hear a lot more than I did.) I didn't hear anything that SUndance sang during the Hollywood round that would have warranted his being put through. That decision had to have been based on personality.
I will be very interested to hear them all sing next week.
